The U.S. economy appears to be teetering on the brink of recession, fuelled by escalating tariffs, policy uncertainty, and market volatility. Experts remain divided on the likelihood and severity of a downturn, but one thing is clear: the automotive industry already feels the effects.
 
Rising Concerns: What the Experts Are Saying
 
Prominent figures in finance are increasingly sounding the alarm. Ray Dalio has warned of a potential “debt death spiral,” with rising government interest costs threatening to squeeze budgets and potentially leading to higher taxes or further borrowing. Meanwhile, Jeremy Grantham has described the current market as a “superbubble,” akin to the 1929 Wall Street Crash, with the Shiller PE ratio at a worrying 38x compared to its historical average of 18x.
 
Mohamed El-Erian has raised the probability of a U.S. recession from 10% to 30%, highlighting a sharp risk increase. Even Warren Buffett, typically a steadfast advocate for U.S. equities, has shifted Berkshire Hathaway’s strategy, doubling its cash reserves to $272 billion while reducing exposure to U.S. stocks. This move suggests a belief that U.S. equities may be overvalued and a downturn could be on the horizon.
 
On the ground, Soros Fund Management’s CIO, Dawn Fitzpatrick, notes that consumer and corporate confidence are “falling off a cliff.” Meanwhile, Ed Yardeni presents a split view: a 55% chance of continued growth (the “Roaring 2020s”) and a 35% chance of a recession and bear market — a significant increase from his previous 20% estimate.
 
The Tariff Turmoil: Policy on the Hoof
 
The trade policies pursued under the “America First” agenda are central to the current instability. Imposing tariffs on imports from Canada, Mexico, and China has introduced significant uncertainty. The erratic nature of these policies — on again, off again — has been likened to “policy on the hoof,” suggesting that these strategies are either poorly thought out or part of a colossal bluff. This unpredictability has made it nearly impossible for businesses to plan effectively, leading many to halt investments and expansion plans.
 
The automotive sector is particularly exposed. The supply chain for vehicles is global, and tariffs on imported components significantly increase costs for manufacturers, who must either pass these on to consumers or absorb them, squeezing tight margins. In the U.S., carmakers such as Ford and General Motors have warned of potential price increases. Meanwhile, European and Asian manufacturers with production bases in the U.S. face similar challenges, especially with retaliatory tariffs from China targeting automotive exports.
 
Impact on Automotive Retail: A View from the Ground
 
Insights from the ICDP report suggest that automotive retailers are already grappling with significant challenges, including supply chain risks, geopolitical tensions, and affordability pressures. The uncertainty around tariffs is exacerbating these challenges. In an environment where affordability is already a critical concern, the potential for price hikes due to tariffs could deter consumers from making large purchases like vehicles.
 
Moreover, the shift towards electric vehicles (EVs) — while a necessary evolution to some — adds complexity. As highlighted by Glenn Mercer in the B2B UK report, regulatory and compliance costs, primarily related to EVs, are set to rise. Tariffs on imported EV components could further inflate costs, slowing down the transition to electric mobility at a time when automakers are heavily investing in this segment.
 
Used Cars and Aftersales: A Silver Lining?
 
Interestingly, the used car market may offer a relative haven. According to recent analysis from Autotrader, used car profits are expected to remain stable or increase slightly, contrasting with the flat or declining outlook for new car sales and finance and insurance (F&I) products. As consumers tighten their belts, demand for used cars could remain robust, providing a buffer for dealerships.
 
Aftersales also presents an opportunity. With new car margins under pressure, dealerships increasingly look to aftersales services to drive profitability. The complexity of EVs, in particular, could boost service revenues, as independent garages may struggle to handle the specialised maintenance these vehicles require.
 
Investing in Uncertain Times: What Should Investors Do?
 
Investors are understandably nervous. With U.S. equities appearing overvalued and policy uncertainty at an all-time high, many are reducing their exposure to the U.S. stock market and looking for opportunities abroad. Warren Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway shift is a significant signal; a cash pile of $272 billion suggests a lack of attractive opportunities at current valuations.
 
Traditionally seen as a cyclical play, the automotive sector is particularly vulnerable. Rising costs, supply chain disruptions, and regulatory uncertainty create a challenging outlook. However, investors with a longer-term horizon may have opportunities in segments less exposed to these risks — such as used cars, aftersales, and electric vehicles. The U.S. economy may or may not tip into a recession, but the risks are rising. The next few months will be critical for the automotive industry. Key strategies for survival will be managing costs, diversifying supply chains, and focusing on areas of stable demand. 

Have a great week!